Manned Versus Unmanned Aircraft Accidents, Including Causation and Rates

Abstract

Verbatim from Embry-Riddle Scholarly Commons. Not paraphrased, not summarized.

Many consider aircraft reliability a primary deterrent to the further integration of unmanned aircraft into civil airspace. Discussions of unmanned aircraft reliability often include comparisons of accident rates of medium and large unmanned aircraft (like the MQ-1 Predator and MQ-9 Reaper) to those of manned aircraft. These comparisons, however, often consider a recent period only but do not consider platform maturity. While this approach is valid—and worthy of discussion—it does not present a complete picture of the unmanned aircraft safety record. This paper employs a chi-square goodness-of-fit approach to compare the progression of the U.S. Air Force MQ-9 mishap rate to that of six manned aircraft flown by the same service. The analysis found that the MQ-9 did not have a significantly different Class A mishap rate progression from the comparison aircraft. The only exception was the F-16, which had a considerably higher rate. In addition, to better understand mishap causation, a comparison of manned to unmanned aircraft mishap causal factors was conducted, primarily relying on journal articles that use the Human Factors and Classification System (HFACS) taxonomy. The analysis found that, like manned aircraft, crew errors contributed to a significant portion of unmanned aircraft accidents, and further, that skill-based errors were often the type of the crew error. The studies also indicated that increasing autonomous control, Human Machine Interface (HMI) design, and crew training will continue to play a significant role in unmanned aircraft mishap causation. Two case studies were also analyzed to highlight differences in manned and unmanned aircraft accident causation.

Authors

• Jaussi, Justin A Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University
• Hoffmann, Herbert O Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University

Keywords

• remotely piloted aircraft
• unmanned aircraft accidents
• mishaps
• mishap rates
• Aviation Safety and Security