Event ERA16LA053

Factual narrative

On December 1, 2015, at 1037 eastern standard time, a Piper PA-32-260, N5568J, was substantially damaged during a forced landing shortly after taking off from Opa Locka Executive Airport (KOPF), Miami, Florida. The private pilot and two passengers sustained serious injuries. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed, and a visual flight rules flight plan had been filed for the flight to South Bimini Airport (MYBS), South Bimini, The Bahamas. The personal flight was operating under the provisions of 14 Code of Federal Regulations Part 91.According to the pilot, as the airplane was climbing through about 800 feet, the front seat passenger asked him if he smelled something. The pilot stated that he did and they both then saw "light smoke up around the dash and windshield area." The pilot commenced a turn back toward the airport, and almost immediately, the engine experienced a total loss of power. The pilot advised the airport tower controller of the problem, but realizing that the airplane could not make it back to the airport, performed a forced landing off-airport. According to the responding Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) inspector, the airplane first touched down on top of a parked tractor trailer, bounced over a canal, and came to rest upside down on a berm. The airplane was recovered to a storage facility where it was subsequently examined with NTSB oversight. There, soot and char marks, along with thermal damage, were noted on the left side of the cowling, both on the engine compartment side and the external side. The left (pilot) side wall of the muffler exhibited metal erosion and was fractured completely around the area where the combined cylinder exhaust pipe attached to the muffler. There were also fractures and bent metal consistent with impact damage. In addition, there was dark staining in the area of the fractures, inboard to cover about 50% of the top of the muffler. Dark staining was additionally noted on the combined cylinder exhaust pipe, most notably near the muffler, and also on the No. 2 (left side, most forward) cylinder intake riser, particularly just above and facing the combined cylinder exhaust pipe. In addition, the valve covers on the left side of the engine displayed thermal darkening on the lower portions of the covers. The engine fuel lines exhibited thermal damage, but were not compromised. The front of the carburetor was charred. The ignition wires on the left side of the engine were charred, with most having lost sections of insulation. Engine crankshaft continuity and cylinder compression were confirmed. The right side wall of the muffler was also stained, and the metal was thin and rusted, with small erosion holes. According to airplane engine and airframe logbooks, the Lycoming O-540E4B5 engine underwent a major overhaul in December 2002, and its installation on the airframe was noted on December 18, 2002, at 0 hours tachometer time. On January 11, 2005, at 122.6 hours tachometer time, the exhaust gaskets were replaced and new hardware was installed. According to the airframe logbook, the airplane's most recent annual/100-hour inspection was completed on June 17, 2015, at 468.8 hours tachometer time. The same mechanic had completed the last three annual/100-hour inspections; no exhaust system anomalies were noted during those inspections. The accident occurred at 476.0 tachometer hours. According to the Piper PA-32-260/300 Service Manual, "A very thorough inspection of the entire exhaust system, including heat exchange shroud, muffler, muffler baffles, stack and all exhaust connections must be accomplished at each 100 hour inspection." (The service manual also described how to inspect the exhaust system and alternative means to inspect it. It also provided a figure that showed typical muffler fatigue areas that included the muffler side walls. FAA Advisory Circular (AC) 91-59A, "Inspection and Care of General Aviation Aircraft Exhaust Systems" emphasizes "the safety hazards of poorly maintained aircraft exhaust systems (reciprocating powerplants) and highlights points at which exhaust system failures occur. Further, it provides information on the kinds of problems to be expected and recommends pilots perform ongoing preventive maintenance and mechanics perform maintenance." The AC also notes that potential failures can include leakage of exhaust gas into the cabin, partial or full engine power loss, or impingement heating or torching of surrounding structures. The private pilot stated that the airplane was climbing through about 800 ft after takeoff when light smoke appeared from the instrument panel and windscreen area. The pilot began a turn back toward the airport, and, almost immediately, the engine experienced a total loss of power. The pilot performed an off-airport forced landing, the airplane struck a parked tractor-trailer, and came to rest inverted on a berm. Subsequent examination of the airplane revealed soot and char marks on the left side of the engine cowling and in the engine compartment. The muffler's left sidewall displayed metal erosion and a wall breach that allowed exhaust gas to leak into the engine compartment. The engine fuel lines exhibited thermal damage but were not compromised. The front of the carburetor was charred, and some magneto leads were burned. The exact means by which the engine lost power could not be determined, but the intense heat of the exhaust gas could have burned off fuel in the carburetor, created a vapor lock in the fuel lines, or interrupted spark to the cylinders. Further examination of the muffler revealed that the right sidewall was thin and rusted and had small erosion holes. The accident occurred less than 8 hours of operation after the airplane's most recent annual/100-hour inspection. Manufacturer-mandated inspection criteria required particular attention be paid to the exhaust system, especially fatigue-prone areas such as the muffler sidewalls. Given the degree of preexisting deterioration noted, it is likely that the exhaust system was not properly inspected during the last inspection. Source: NTSB Aviation Accident Database Retrieved: 2026-02-12

NTSB Findings

Hierarchical cause / factor breakdown from the FAA bulk avdata database. Each finding tagged C (Cause) or F (Factor).

• C Personnel issues-Task performance-Inspection-Scheduled/routine inspection-Maintenance personnel - C
• C Aircraft-Aircraft power plant-Engine exhaust-(general)-Inadequate inspection - C
• C Aircraft-Aircraft power plant-Engine exhaust-(general)-Failure - C
• C Aircraft-Aircraft power plant-Engine exhaust-(general)-Fatigue/wear/corrosion - C